Hey everyone! Today’s post is a really special one for me.
A few days ago, one of my former students sent me an email that I definitely wasn’t expecting. It was such an important email and message that I felt like I had to share it with all of you. Fortunately, he gave me permission to put the entire email in this post.
Before you read it, let me explain why this matters:
As you’ve probably seen me write 1,000x times, one of the biggest reasons that I left my teaching job three years ago is that I realized I was passionate about teaching personal finance.
After I paid off my student loans, I started looking for opportunities to talk to my students about money. Honestly…I wasn’t doing it with the intention of leaving my job or anything like that.
I just wanted to teach my students things about money that I didn’t know.
Every week, we were supposed to teach these advisory lessons that the principal emailed out to the teaching staff. They were ultra-boring. I didn’t want to teach them haha (which is probably a good indicator that I needed to work for myself).
So…I ignored those lessons and taught my own. I wanted to teach the kids about personal finance.
It wasn’t anything crazy – literally just the basics of personal finance. Credit, debt, interest, stocks vs. bonds, and I think I even threw in one about 403b’s (because that’s what the district wanted teachers to contribute extra funds to at the time and I was mad about it).
Long story short…that became the catalyst for me leaving my teaching job. I originally wanted to teach seminars and travel to different high schools, but M$M started growing pretty quickly and I realized that I could reach so many more people with this site.
But back to the email – it floored me. There’s nothing super-intense or sappy in it. But for me, it was an awesome message to receive from a former student. As any teacher (or former teacher) knows…you never know exactly how much of an impact you’re going to have on your students. Some never talk to you again. Some have their lives completely changed by one small thing that you told them and don’t even remember doing.
It’s pretty incredible, really.
I think the important thing here is that the simple lessons I taught stuck with this young man. He doesn’t know it yet, but he’s already so far beyond most of his peers for even thinking about the things that you’re about to see in the email he sent me.
I guess to boil it all down – I’m proud. I’m proud of him for listening to me a few years ago (as a teacher you’re never quiiiiite sure that the kids actually listen to you). I’m proud of the work that I’ve done with this site and the community we’ve all created.
And most importantly, I’m proud to see the proof that the things we say to kids about money can change the entire direction of their relationship with personal finance.
Here’s the letter from my former student:
Hey Bobby,
Austin C. here. I’ve been catching up on some M$M reading lately and thought I’d send you an email to keep in touch. As always, I think the site and all its ventures are fantastic and based on your monthly income reports it seems there are plenty of others who think that too.
I’ve noticed in a lot of your articles you’ve mentioned how you used to be a band director, how you taught your students about money instead of what you were supposed to, and how you felt trapped in that job. As your students, being young and oblivious, we never considered on the days that you were frustrated that there could have been more going on in the background than just “he’s mad because we can’t match our stick heights and walk at the same time.”
It’s always funny to me when I read your articles and see how much you’ve achieved chasing this passion of yours because I can still personally remember Bobby Hoyt the band director trying to whip us into shape, and not just Bobby Hoyt the finance blogger. Reading your articles through that unique lens adds a depth to your writing for me. It’s been so interesting following your pursuits from the very beginning, like when you’d spend lunch breaks working on generating twitter traffic, and to look at where you’re at now.
To say the very least, congratulations on everything you’ve achieved, and will continue to achieve. I will always wish you the best of luck.
I can’t speak for the rest of your students I graduated with, but I know for certain that your money advisory lessons shaped my views on personal finance from the very beginning. You weren’t teaching us anything crazy or obscure, just simple stuff like “What is credit.”
But you introducing those concepts to me inspired and motivated me to do my own learning about personal finance, and I’ve learned so much over just the past three years. It inspired me to open an investment account and take an interest in my credit score and think about all the important financial decisions I’ll make in the next 5 years of my life, among many other things. I highly doubt I would have thought about any of these things until I graduated college if it wasn’t for your encouragement to learn more about money.
Additionally, I look back on your teaching and realized that whatever it was you were trying to get us to do or learn, you were imparting on us to actively pursue bettering ourselves, and to never just passively hope things will get better, or “mail it in.” The success and state of M$M today speaks for itself in that regard; it didn’t become what it is by passively hoping. I sincerely thank you for that, and I just thought you should know how much of an impact it made on me.
The other day I checked on my investment account just to see how it was doing, which I don’t do very often. Everything looked fine and dandy, and I was happy to see that the price of the ETF I invested in 3 years ago had increased 30%. But then I realized, damn, I’ll likely never be able to buy at that original price ever again. It was kind of an awakening.
I decided that day that I would start setting aside 5% of my income to invest. I realized I can’t go back 3 years and buy more shares, but what I can do is not lose any more time in the market and start adding more to my investment account now. I can’t afford to throw all my money at investing, but every little bit will count both now and in 30 years.
Also, I just received my first credit card. I applied for one last year but was denied because of my credit score. It was really low because I only had one line of credit which was a student loan, and no other history. But my score improved, and I got the plastic in the mail the other day.
I’m going to use it as a credit building tool so I can improve my credit score and history before I graduate: gasoline purchases only, less than 9% utilization, paid in full every month after the statement is reported. I’m interested to see how much of a positive impact on my score I can make with this.
In other regards, I’m just trying to finish college, trying to secure a job offer for when I graduate, and planning and looking forward to my near future post-college life.
Again, I wish you and Coral all the best in your endeavors.
– Austin C.
A quick note…
If you’re a teacher, a parent, or anyone that has a young person in your life that you think could benefit from learning something about money…please, teach them. It doesn’t have to be crazy. You don’t have to deep-dive into taxes or estate planning.
It can be simple. The only thing you need to do is spark their curiosity, and they’ll do the rest. Remember – kids know how to use the internet to figure things out better than even Millennials do! It’s kinda crazy haha.
But seriously – if you could change the direction of one kid’s life by getting them interested in money…why wouldn’t you? It’s too good of an opportunity to pass up (in my opinion).
Question for you:
Who was the first person to teach you about personal finance?
A very beautiful note. Welldone, Bobby!
Such letters make all the hard work worth it.
It’s my first time on your site and I have to congratulate you for such great content.
Keep it up!
I agree – it does make it so much more worth it!
What beautiful feedback from your former student. It’s a great reminder that we may never know the impact our words have on someone else – so be careful which words you allow to be spoken.
The first person to teach me about money was my mom – an RN, and also the money manager in our home. Despite the fact that my dad was a CPA. I always thought that was weird! Lol. But she taught me to track my spending, to budget, to save, and indirectly to invest by paying for a subscription to Money magazine for probably the first 15 years of my adult life. She also taught me that you don’t need to be a “finance” person to invest in individual stocks. She and a bunch of other nurses had an investment club that met monthly and made investments as a club for years. They had some big wins, relatively few losses. And I can’t believe I still remember this almost 40 years later…
Haha that is weird! Maybe he just didn’t want to talk about it since it was his day job?
Totally agree – you never know what words people will pick up on.
As someone who is a teacher currently I know thank you notes from students are few and far between. When you do get one (especially one like this) it just totally knocks your socks off.
Congrats on having such a great influence on your former students!
Yeah they don’t come often, but they are awesome when they do 🙂
My Dad’s first advice to us about money was something he called Finance 101: “When your outgo exceeds your income, your upkeep will become your downfall.”
Pretty good advice! 🙂
I developed the habit early of making deliberate, intentional spending choices, and it’s served me well.
I like that!
Wow! That’s a Awesome! Proud moment for you, for sure!
It was!!!!!!!!
No one. No one has taught me about personal finance. How’d that work out, you ask? Between house and school loans I’m $150K+ in debt. So not so much. But we cover our monthly’s so I can’t complain. Need to spend more time on your site reading.👍🏻
Man I didn’t know much either about 5 years ago. Once you start, you can change your life pretty quickly.
Wow that’s so awesome! It’s amazing how you got a blast from the past. It’s nice that one of your students reached out to you and is even following your journey. Who knows, maybe after he graduates from college, he’ll start a blog of his own.
Wow, this is awesome! So cool seeing how you made an impact a few years ago that has completely changed how he views personal finance and inspired him to do his own learning. Thanks for sharing this.
Wow. A note like that will make you stop and ponder for a moment about how much impact one person, one teacher, one advisory class, and one blog can have. You changed that kids’ entire future for himself and his future family. He’s investing and being intentional with his money. Those are life-changing decisions right there. Cheers to making an impact, both as Bobby Hoyt Band Director and Bobby Hoyt the Finance Blogger. 🙂
Wow, that is a powerful letter. I wonder what it would look like if every M$M reader did the same thing and wrote a letter to a teacher that had an impact on our lives in a very formative time.
I am inspired by Austin to do this same thing.
What an awesome letter! I work at a university and teach a freshman course (basically how to be a college student 101) and we spend one day doing very basic personal finance i.e. how to set up a budget, understanding financial aid (student loans), how to live within our means, why credit cards can be good/bad. While I’ve yet to have a student tell me they appreciate it, my hope is that I’m at least exposing them to something that can help them as college students. I love when you make a positive impact on someone and they take the time to let you know 🙂 Great job Bobby!
What a great letter, and so proud of him for actually TAKING the advice. I hope my teachings stick with my son. I didn’t grow up with the best personal finance knowledge, and you’re never too old to learn, but the younger the better 🙂
Love this! I didn’t learn a lick of personal finance until after I accrued $650k of student loan debt (yikes) and started reading every personal finance book I could get my hands on, which oddly started with Robert Kiyosaki’s book Rich Dad Poor Dad (which doesn’t really teach about personal finance, but is motivating to make more money). So I guess he’s the first person that got me on the personal finance path! and ultimately blogging about it 🙂
This is such an awesome e-mail from a former student – and the fact that he has been following you all of these years is something else. Honestly, I can’t remember most of my teachers, let alone wonder where they are now. You definitely impacted this young man in such a profound way and made a difference in his financial future. That gives me chills. Kudos Bobby, you are doing amazing things and helping so many people!
This makes sense! Kids need to learn money as early as they can! I wrote a post about affiliate marketing which is somewhat unrelated but it’s interesting.